Oh, I do love this! Especially the epilogue, it's so sweet.
Well, the Doctor may suspect that he will know her, but he's not saying. Thanks for sharing.
Entertaining and interesting.
Interesting mystery here. We still don't know if it is supernatural or alien. Nicely done.
Quite a few different communities on Long Island even in 1959. So my comment is that they probably would have wanted to request more specific information (what part of Long Island) unless the Doctor was able to look back on the boys' timelines to determine where they generally all were together a few nights ago.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Long_Island_Rail_Road
Author's Response: Thanks for your reviews! (I thought I\'d specified Brooklyn Heights, though? Or did I accidentally leave that part out? If so--eep! Thanks for catching that; I\'ll put that back in!)
Very nice. I wasn't expecting Amy and Rory to be the clients, but you gave this reader enough clues.