Reviews For Ice and Fire

2010.02.27 - 07:46PM
1: Chapter 1

That. Was. Gorgeous. I could hear Nimoy in my head, and the common thread of the two stories was brought out beautifully.

Author's Response: Yay! And hearing Nimoy in your head for this is the greatest possible compliment I could be paid, I think. Thank you!!!

2009.12.11 - 09:15PM
1: Chapter 1

You captured both characters so perfectly, and merged their universes and their griefs beautifully. This is what a crossover is meant to be.

Author's Response: Thank you very much! I don\'t write crossovers often, so I\'m very glad it worked for you!

2009.07.01 - 12:32AM
1: Chapter 1

Wiser but not older, older but not wiser.

Author's Response: Pretty much. :)

2009.06.13 - 01:25PM
1: Chapter 1

I never, repeat never read crossover fics. I find the genre's inconsistant which ever two they are and often credulity is stretched to breaking point in order to make a fic work - BUT this was a work of genius. The ideas were strong and the links between the characters clevely wrought. I don't know why I read it but I'm very glad I did. Thank you.

Author's Response: I know exactly how you feel about crossovers, believe me - I\'ve found a few that are pure genius, but too often they don\'t seem to work. I was *deathly* afraid this would fall into the latter category even as I wrote it, but it wouldn\'t leave me alone... so I\'m extremely glad it worked for you! Thanks so much for reading and commenting. :)

2009.06.13 - 09:07AM
1: Chapter 1

I have only one criticism, and I'll get it right out of the way: keep your tenses consistent. Easy to flip between past and present when the muse hits, I know.

With that done, excellent story! I could really hear Spock and Nine talking. You nailed both their characters. The ending is so poignant. It's lovely that you gave Nine someone as wise as Spock to grieve with.

Author's Response: Oh, drat, you\'re right - I did it again. Every time I think I\'ve kicked that bad habit it bites me again. Thank you so much for letting me know!!! I\'m glad you liked the two of them together... now I just have to go back and do a bit of editing. ;)

2009.06.12 - 08:14PM
1: Chapter 1

What a fantastically fascinating story! Well done.

Author's Response: Thank you! I\'m very pleased you liked it!

2009.06.12 - 08:04PM
1: Chapter 1

Not fair you made me cry!!! Our poor 9 and and equally sad Spock what a combo.

Author's Response: Awww, I\'m sorry. ;) I\'m very glad you enjoyed, though!