Reviews For Festive Restings

2008.05.19 - 11:49AM
1: Looking Skywards

That was really good - great to see Benny in something again. You had her spot on. (Loved the bit about her early retirement & the emails...)

2007.12.22 - 11:58PM
1: Looking Skywards

That was well worth the wait! I have to confess, though, that I almost stopped reading when poor Wolsey passed away; that hit a little too close to home for me. But then you slipped in and made things happy again--that much more so for the poignancy you'd created. Your characterizations of Benny and the Doctor were charmingly perfect, too. As always, lovely work!

2007.12.22 - 09:32PM
1: Looking Skywards

Oh, this was lovely. True to form for Benny, too. I can almost hear her "voice" from the novels and the audios throughout this fic. And Ten was spot on. Then, having Seven stop in for a Christmas miracle was absolutely lovely. Left me with a smile on my face, especially given the ending.

Thank you so much for sharing!

Author's Response: Glad you liked it & happy hols!

wmr
2007.12.22 - 09:23PM
1: Looking Skywards

I've never read any of the Benny novels, apart from the last couple of chapters of the one with Eight, but I do have a fair idea of her character. And this is just lovely :) Sad and regretful and tainted with loss, as much for her Doctor as for Wolsey, and you also manage to convey the Tenth Doctor's sense of loss also - in some ways, you never can go back.

But then that final section, where Benny's Doctor came through for her and gives her a Christmas miracle after all, is gorgeous :) Really nice work!

Author's Response: Cheers for that, hope you have a safe and restive holiday!