|Yorda||2009.08.28 - 10:05PM||2: A Chance Encounter...||Signed|
|Usually, I don't like an author-created Doctor, but this Doctor is awesome! Love the fact that neither Doctor nor Rose recognizes each other. Love the chasing the squirrel through the park part--that's sooo Doctor and Rose. Love it, love it, love it!|
Author's Response: Why thank you so much :)
|Violet||2008.07.10 - 11:11AM||1: A Welcome Distraction...||Signed|
|wonderful. totally in character. You had me on the edge of my seat even though I could guess what would probably happen.|
I avoided this one for a while because I didn't want something too sad right now. I'm glad I decided to brave it this morning.
Author's Response: awwwww why thank you very much :)
|Kazzy||2008.06.21 - 06:29PM||3: Chapter 3||Signed|
|It's not often I read around here anymore. But I'm glad I clicked the link to this rec. Reading this fic made my morning. I can't say what I love abobut this best, but I do love the whole idea of them meeting after so long and having no idea who they are - it just made their eventual reunion all the better. Thank you! :)|
Author's Response: why thank you very much!
|Unseen Watcher||2008.03.02 - 10:56PM||1: A Welcome Distraction...||Signed|
|I do admit that it's a bit confusing that this is in the 'Tenth Doctor' section. I might have never found it! *gasps in horror* |
Still enjoying it and printing it out for sanity reasons when I can't be at the computer. ^_~
Author's Response: The first part was supposed to be a one-off, and since there really was no doctor in it, tenth seemed good! maybe I should relabel it as \"other\" doctors or somethign?
|Unseen Watcher||2008.02.06 - 11:03PM||2: A Chance Encounter...||Signed|
|This is the best Author Created Doctor I've ever encoutered. He's so believable that I think I just automatically accepted him. Now /that's/ talented. I'm very impressed.|
Author's Response: Oh wow thanks very much!!!
|Shen||2007.10.11 - 02:03PM||3: Chapter 3||Signed|
|This made me smile. :)|
Author's Response: Glad i could provide a smile :)
|Kathy DaCat||2007.03.31 - 10:59AM||1: A Welcome Distraction...||Signed|
|=-) I wish...|
Author's Response: hehe. so do I, obviously...
|jessdoctorwho21||2007.03.31 - 05:57AM||3: Chapter 3||Signed|
Author's Response: thanks :)
|Wiliam||2007.03.30 - 09:29PM||3: Chapter 3||Signed|
|guh. So perfect it's frozen my tongue. I just wanna sorta... bask...|
But I'll try to give a review, because you more than deserve one.
The ending was absolutely ideal! Of course, I'm completely Jack-happy, so anytime the three of them get reunited, I go into spasms of bliss. The weirder the way, the more I like it.
A cat named Tabatha? It took me a while to work out what the litter-box thing was. Now I feel stupid. Heh... Rose became a crazy-cat lady in her old age. *giggle*
One issue that is bothering me is how did she see the Doctor and her younger self in the park at the start?
I like how you used the Zeppelins to indicate the universe- it was sorta... understated, and nice.
And then the whole great romance... 8D
It couldn't have been done better. Thankyou for a fantastic read. (favourites)
Author's Response: just a tabby type of cat :) she was watching another couple that reminded her an awful lot of her and the Doctor in the first part. yes ,she became a crazy cat lady LOL. Glad you enjoyed and thanks for the long, enthusiastic review!
|kiss_her_theta||2007.03.30 - 09:24PM||3: Chapter 3||Signed|
|omg!! i love this idea!!!!!!!!! :D|
Author's Response: thanks very much :) glad you enjoyed :)
|Wiliam||2007.03.30 - 09:13PM||2: A Chance Encounter...||Signed|
|I think I'm falling in love with this story. I assumed it was just a one-shot. Amazingly, as is so very rare in fanfic, the 2nd chapter was better than the stand-alone would have been. You've gotten me all excited. I like how you've aged Rose. I won't ask too many quesitons, because I trust you to resolve them later (like, what universe are they in exactly, and why is Rose immortal?). Going to read the next chappie now. (also adore your update speed ;D)|
ps. 'which she couldn’t bare' That should be bear (synonym for tolerate, stand, put up with, as opposed to naked, or exposed).
Author's Response: maybe I was trying to be clever, you don\'t know ;) hehehe.
I thought it was just a one-shot too, but a second part decided it wanted to be written. I am but a humble servant :) hopefully you\'ll like the third part too ;)
|wmr||2007.03.30 - 07:08PM||3: Chapter 3||Signed|
|Copied over from the other fic:|
I loved this third chapter - loved the Doctor and Jack's conversation, the Doctor going back for 'Roslyn', and then Jack snogging Rose at the end. Great work!
One little nitpick, though - you have Rose say:
“God. I usually make sure I get a last name before rolling in the hay with somebody. It figures the one time I don’t , it’s because it’s you.”
And then, just a few lines below, there's this exchange:
His cheek twitched. “Yeah. Conveniant excuse. Never dawned on you when I said my name was John Smith?”
Rose rolled her eyes. “D’you know how many John Smiths I’ve met in the last hundred and eighty years?
She did get his surname... :)
Author's Response: LOL you\'re too kind. She knew his name wasn\'t john and that smith was an alias. girl tries to get a real last name before tumbling in the hay with a fellow. I hope. Otherwise that\'s just slutty LOL
|LilStarKat||2007.03.30 - 03:38PM||2: A Chance Encounter...||Signed|
|omg its the doctor isnt it?!? she really must have changed for the doctor not to have recognised her (that depends whether it is the doctor or not lol =P)|
really going well so far, really loving it! plz update soon! =)
Author's Response: I think I just did. Possibly correctly this time too LOL
|wmr||2007.03.29 - 09:18PM||2: A Chance Encounter...||Signed|
|Oh, wow, wow, wow! Amazing! So the Doctor's regenerated, and this is a long, long time after Doomsday, and - has Rose regenerated, or is she just disguising herself well? |
And I love the comments about Jack. And especially the 'he'd love to watch' bit. No, he wouldn't - he'd want to join in, and we'd all want him to!
But then you left it there and... *splutter splutter* More!
Author's Response: more soon :) promise :) glad you enjoyed.
|Pink_Rose||2007.03.29 - 01:09PM||2: A Chance Encounter...||Signed|
|Excellent! Even better than the first, I think. Can't wait for more! |
Author's Response: hopefully it won\'t be too long before the other part of this is done :) glad you enjoyed!